The Pay Transparency Playbook: Building Trust Through Open Compensation

Welcome to the Vantage HR influencers podcast. This podcast is sponsored by Vantage Circle, the simple and AI powered rewards and recognition platform for employee engagement.

Shabana Shahnaz: Hello, everyone. Welcome to another episode of the Vantage influencers podcast. I'm your host, Shabana Shahnaz. And today we are diving into a topic that's transforming how organizations think about compensation, the pay transparency playbook, building trust through open compensation. Pay transparency has been making headlines, but it's more than just publishing salary ranges. It's about creating an environment of trust, accountability, and equity. The question now is how do organizations get it right without creating confusion or unintended consequences? To help us unpack this, I am joined by a seasoned strategic talent acquisition leader, Debolina Bhattacharyya, with over 14 years of experience driving scalable recruitment strategies across global consulting firms and high-growth tech organizations. Debolina is also a strong advocate for DEI focused hiring, employer branding, and data driven decision making, all of which directly ties into how companies approach pay transparency. A very warm welcome to the show, Debolina. It's a pleasure to have you with us for today's episode. Please tell us how are you feeling today?

Debolina Bhattacharyya: Hey, Shabana. Thank you so much for the introduction. I am feeling good. I'm feeling great, actually. How are you feeling?

Shabana Shahnaz: Well, I'm very excited for the show. So before we get into the deeper stuff, then we can just ground ourselves in the basics, right? So when we talk about pay transparency, what are we really talking about? Is it purely about fairness or is there a bigger picture here?

Debolina Bhattacharyya: That's actually a very good question that's at the tone of this session. I think most people think that pay transparency is just about fairness. And yes, that's definitely a part of it, but it actually goes much, much deeper. It's more about clarity and trust is what I feel. It means that people should understand how pay decisions are made, what factors are considered, where they stand in the business or in the system. So when these kind of questions get answered to pay transparency, that actually boosts the overall organizational behavior as well as the culture of the company. So it has very, very deep impact in any organization.

Shabana Shahnaz: Right. That is so beautifully put. So Debolina, I think a lot of leaders say openness is one of the fastest ways to build credibility with teams, right? So how does it actually play out in practice? Like have you seen any real world examples where transparency has changed company dynamics?

Debolina Bhattacharyya: I have, I have. And I think that's pretty much out in the open. So I'll give an example which recently came out of this company Buffer. It's kind of a mid-sized firm and they made it pretty open. Actually, they even told the salary ranges and how they come up with it. What is the formula behind it? So it was pretty much out there in the open. And as for the company statistics, it seems it really helped them to build up their employee engagement and overall company morale. But I think every company has its own journey towards it. If you ask me, this is a very, very bold step and it needs to be taken based on where your company or your organization stands in the ecosystem.

Shabana Shahnaz: Right. That is a very bold step. I'm actually intrigued knowing this. So well, I've also seen leaders who worry like sharing too much could create tension or dissatisfaction. But I want to know your take, like what's your take on it? Like if those concerns do come up, how can companies address them without retreating to secrecy? Like how do you think should companies actually handle those concerns?

Debolina Bhattacharyya: Yeah, I think it's a very common fear. I always say that transparency doesn't create tension. It actually eases it. And that's the mindset you need to inculcate within your organization. If there's a pay disparity or any inconsistency, that is where dissatisfaction comes in. So instead of shying away, I feel a company should embrace it. But it has to be like one step at a time. You cannot jump into it. You have to first understand your business leaders' mindset. Why are they kind of not completely okay with it? What can you do to ensure that you both come to a common consensus? And most importantly, train the reporting managers, people at mid manager level, because these are the people who have discussions with their respective team members. And they play a very, very critical role. So training them, making them understand how the communication can happen, I feel should definitely ease out the gap. And that's the confidence also you need to put it forward with the proper data to the leadership. I think if you are able to do that, and back it up with data, I'm sure people do understand and recognize that.

Shabana Shahnaz: Correct. I agree. I completely agree. So how do you think HRs and leadership work together to communicate salary structures in a way that's both honest and empowering for employees? Like what I want to ask is, what are the first practical steps a company should take before launching any kind of a transparency strategy?

Debolina Bhattacharyya: I think, yes, definitely, the first step should be that the HR and the leadership has to be in sync. And that's the reason in my previous answer, I said you cannot jump in. These are small steps you take towards it. So firstly, you need to collaborate with the leadership and understand on what basis the pay is given to them. Is it based on their experience? Is it based on the tenure, their skills? What they bring on to the table? Or is it market competency mapping? Or is it a mix of everything? And if it's a mix of everything, what ratings will they give as importance to all these parameters? So there are a lot of things that need to be looked into when you are talking to the leadership. Multiple meetings, multiple data points, their point of view, their team members' data, a lot of things will come into picture when you're talking to them. So once you come to a common consensus, that's when you have to start communicating that slowly to the people at the mid-level. And while you are communicating that, it's again, as I said, a very, very tricky situation. When you are communicating salary to anybody, you have to be very, very empathetic and not point it out in a way that puts pressure on the reporting person. So I believe here that is where the L&D department comes in. You have to train your managers, senior managers, or people at this mid-level to ensure that they understand how the communication needs to happen. Once you communicate properly, I think once people have that feeling that they are getting a proper view of why what is given to them and what should they do as a growth path to move ahead, I'm pretty sure they start feeling included. And that's when you also see the retention slowly going higher for a company. So it's very important that you communicate it well.

Shabana Shahnaz: Okay, so that was insightful. I think I completely agree with all the steps you've actually mentioned. But then, even with a great plan, there are always certain myths that float around, like those half truths or fears that stop companies from even trying. So what do you think are some of the biggest myths or misconceptions that you have come across when it comes to pay transparency?

Debolina Bhattacharyya: Yeah, quite a few actually. The first big myth is whenever you say pay transparency, I think people think that it's like disclosing every individual salary. So that is not true. I think it just simply means being open about the process and the rationale behind it, the ranges and your growth path. What should you do to move to the next level and to ensure you hit that certain salary range to go to that next level? So it's more about the rationale, not about exact figures. And the next point, which we spoke briefly during our earlier questions, is that transparency leads to conflict. That's again one common myth. I don't think so. Yes, there is a way that you communicate, and that is where your training sessions and everything come into picture. But I don't think it's conflicting. If communicated properly with empathy and with proper reasons, and making the person understand that they are included within the company, it's not that we are trying to find faults in them, we are trying to help them grow to the next level and hence increase that certain salary which they are looking at. So if you are communicating it properly, I don't think the point goes into everybody's mind that it's a conflict. But it's a very, very sensitive issue and you cannot jump on it overnight. It has to be slowly through multiple internal organization processes.

Shabana Shahnaz: Correct. So I think I'm not surprised at all. It should be pretty obvious to everyone, but then yes, it is a very sensitive topic. So people do have fears and questions around it. So I think we can just wrap this session with something very actionable for our listeners then. Not every company is ready to go fully transparent overnight. For some companies who are just getting started, what do you think are a few early wins or some small changes they can make that still move the needle forward for more transparency?

Debolina Bhattacharyya: I think first and foremost is definitely HR and leadership should be on a common consensus ground. So you need to talk and understand what should be your compensation philosophy. As I said, will it be market transparency? Will it be based on skills? Whatever it is, but you should hit a common ground on that. That's first and foremost. And next, based on that, there are multiple ways you can come up with your internal salary bands. There are multiple agencies in the market who do this kind of specific work where they help in building up salary bands for certain organizations. So you can reach out to agencies who help you in that. Or secondly, there are multiple job portals available, which again, if you can dig deep into that, do in-depth research based on the kind of skills you plan to hire or the kind of experience range of people you want to hire, based on that as well, you can come up with your internal parity data. So to sum it up, first is hitting the common ground with leadership and understanding what would be the philosophy. Second is you can reach out to specific agencies who are specialized in that and take their help in designing your salary bands. And third would be, depending on what stage the company is at, if you don't want to invest that money, then you can definitely look at different portals available in the market, do your research, dig into it, and then come up with your internal salary bands. And also, as a next step, once you have fixed up these things, it's very important to run a pay equity audit. That may not be right away. Let's say once you have done your initial set of hires, probably after a year or a year and a half, you can run a pay equity audit to understand where the compensation structure of your company stands vis-a-vis the market. That also helps you keep pace with what the market is, because let's admit, people are very smart nowadays. Everybody knows how the market is. So you have to also be on top of your game to ensure that you are setting the right expectations within the company.

Shabana Shahnaz: Of course, you actually put it across so well and so easy to understand for everyone, even if it is for beginners who are just starting new companies or the giants, let's say. So I think it was a very insightful conversation, Debolina. Thank you so much for sharing your time and such thoughtful insights with us today. We've covered a lot, from what pay transparency really means to even small steps that can actually start building trust to start with. So I think our listeners will actually walk away with plenty to think about and maybe even come up with a few ideas they can try in their respective workplaces. Overall, this conversation I think was very helpful. So thank you so much once again, Debolina. And even to our lovely audiences, thank you audiences for actually tuning in. So yes, I think we'll see everyone the next time.

Debolina Bhattacharyya: Thank you so much, Shabana. Thank you for having me in this particular session. I thoroughly enjoyed it. And I am pretty sure with whatever conversations we had, there should definitely be a takeaway with the audience. But yeah, thanks again for having me here.

Shabana Shahnaz: Of course, of course. Thank you so much.

(upbeat music)